Proto's Pizza
HomeMenuReviewsAboutOrder now

Proto's Pizza Menu

Alcohol (Must be 21 to Purchase)


Homemade Sangria

32 oz. Must be 21 to Purchase.

$20.00

Heineken Beer

12 oz. can. Must be 21 to Purchase.

$6.00

Corona Beer

12 oz. can. Must be 21 to Purchase.

$6.00

Red Wine Cabernet

Small bottle, 187 ml. Must be 21 to Purchase.

$6.00

Big Game SPECIALS


Big Game Package #1

18" Cheese Pizza, 10 Buffalo Wings, 10 Mozzarella Fritti .

$45.95

Big Game Package #2

20 Buffalo Wings, 15 Mozzarella Fritti, 7 Chicken Tenders, French Fries.

$67.95

Big Game Package #3

18" Cheese Pizza, 18" Pepperoni Pizza, 30 Buffalo Wings, 20 Mozzarella Fritti, 20 Garlic Knots

$129.95

Beverages


Soda

$2.50

Poland Spring

$1.50

Iced Tea

$3.00

Gatorade

$3.00

Salads


Proto's Salad

Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, onions, feta cheese served with home made Italian dressing.

$12.00 +

Caesar Salad

$12.00 +

Mozzarella & Tomato Salad

With basil and balsamic vinaigrette.

$12.00

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Romaine lettuce with Buffalo Chicken cutlet,bacon,tomatoes,cucumbers,onions,crumbled blue cheese topped with ranch dressing

$15.00

Appetizers


Garlic Bread

$4.00 +

Dough Balls Formaggi

$6.00

Buffalo Wings

7pcs.

$15.00

Mozzarella Fritti

7pcs.

$10.00

Meatballs

Four homemade beef meatballs

$13.00

French Fries

$5.00

Heros


Chicken Roll

All natural chicken lightly fried with cheese and tomato sauce rolled in our home made dough

$10.00 +

Chicken Parm Hero

Served on a 6" Home made Hero bread.

$13.00 +

Meatball Hero

Served on a 6" Home made Hero bread..

$13.00 +

Eggplant Parm Hero

Served on a 6" Home made Hero bread.

$13.00 +

Sausage, Onions and Peppers Hero

Served on a 6" Home made Hero Bread

$13.00 +

Cold Italian Sub

Sopressata, ham, prosciutto, fresh mozzerella and lettuce.

$13.00 +

Chicken Parm Hero with Vodka sauce

Served in a 6” homemade bread and homemade creamy vodka sauce

$13.00 +

Proto’s Phillycheesesteak

Steak, mozzarella, onions, red peppers and jalapeños

$13.00

Pasta


Pesto Mushroom Ravioli

Basil pesto sauce.

$16.00 +

Penne Vodka

Creamy tomato sauce.

$16.00 +

Spaghetti Primavera

Cherry tomatoes, black olives, roasted peppers and capers with garlic and olive oil.

$16.00 +

Baked Ravioli

Four cheese ravioli with melted mozzarella and home made marinara.

$16.00 +

Bake Zitti

Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella and Ricotta

$16.00 +

Rigatoni Amatriciana

Tomato Sauce, Onions, and Pacetta

$16.00 +

Spaghetti and Meat Balls

$17.00 +

Rigatoni Marinara

Fresh daily homemade tomato sauce

$12.00 +

Pene Alfredo

$16.00 +

Rigatoni Carbonara

$16.00 +

Rigatoni Pesto Sauce

$16.00 +

Spaghetti Bolognese

$17.00 +

Entrees


Chicken Parm

Served with a choice of pasta in our homemade marinara sauce.

$19.00

Eggplant Parm

Served with a choice of pasta in our homemade marinara sauce.

$18.00

Sausage and Meatballs

Served with a choice of pasta in our homemade marinara sauce.

$19.00

Chicken Francaise

Served with a choice of pasta in our homemade marinara sauce.

$21.00

Chicken Parm Vodka Sauce

served with a choice of pasta in a creamy vodka sauce

$21.00

Proto’s Chicken

Lightly breaded chicken cutlet topped with diced tomatoes, onions,arugula and balsamic dressing. Served with a choice of pasta in our homemade marinara sauce.

$19.00 +

Chicken Fingers


8oz. Hamburger with Fries and Soda

8oz. Angus burger w/lettuce,tomato and onion

$14.00 +

8oz. Cheeseburger with Fries and Soda

8oz. Angus burger w/American Cheese,lettuce,tomato and onion

$15.00 +

Buffalo Chicken Tenders w/Fries

4 Pieces of Buffalo Chicken Tenders with fries and blue cheese

$13.00

Pizza by the Slice


Cheese Slice

$4.50 +

With Toppings

$5.50 +

Specialty Slice

$4.25

Personal 10" Pizza


10" Personal Cheese Pie

$12.50 +

10" Buffalo Chicken Pie

$15.50 +

10" Bacon Chicken Ranch

$15.50 +

10" BBQ Chicken Pie

$15.50 +

10 '' Square Grandma Pie

$16.50 +

10" Vegan Pizza

Garlic, Roasted Peppers , Mushrooms, Spinach finished over Homes made Tomato Sauce

$13.50 +

10” Chorizo and Jalapeno Pizza

Chorizo, jalapeno, red onion and drizzle of Mikes hot honey

$15.50 +

10" Pizza Florentine

Spinach, Egg, Olives, Garlic, Cheese and Tomato Sauce

$14.00 +

Specialty Thin Crust 14" Pizza


14" Cheese Pizza

$20.00 +

14" Marinara Pizza

Tomato sauce, garlic, oregano and basil.

$18.00 +

14" Margherita Pizza

Fresh mozzarella and basil.

$23.00 +

14" Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza

$24.00 +

14" BBQ Chicken Pizza

$24.00 +

14" Buffalo Chicken Pizza

$24.00 +

14" Chorizo and Jalapeno Pizza

Chorizo, jalapeno, red onions and a drizzle of Hot Honey

$24.00 +

14" Pizza Florentine

Spinach, Egg, Olives, Garlic, Cheese and Tomato Sauce

$22.00 +

14" Lasagna Pizza

$24.00 +

14" Quattro Formaggi Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, Pecorino, Gorgonzola, Parmigiana and caramelized onions.

$24.00 +

14" Prosciutto Di Parma

Fresh mozzarella, Pecorino, garlic and arugula.

$24.00 +

14" Sopressata Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, sopressata, oregano and black olives.

$24.00 +

14" Proto's Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, calamata olives, roasted peppers, mushrooms, beef smoked sausage

$24.00 +

14" Vegan Pizza

Garlic, Roasted Peppers, Mushrooms, Spinach finished over Home made Tomato Sauce

$22.00 +

14" Vodka Sauce and Bacon Pie

Fresh mozzarella, vodka sauce and bacon

$24.00 +

14" White Pizza

$23.00 +

Large 18" Pizza


Cheese Pizza Pie

$25.00 +

White Pizza Pie

$29.00 +

Buffalo Chicken Pie

$32.95 +

BBQ Chicken Pie

$32.95 +

Bacon, Chicken Ranch

$32.95 +

Grandma Pie

$31.95 +

Square Sicilian Pie

$30.00 +

Meat Lover Pie

$34.00 +

Lasagna Pie

$31.95 +

Cream Spinach Pie

$30.95 +

Margherita

$29.00 +

Meatball Pie

$30.95 +

Vegan Pizza

Garlic, Roasted Peppers, Mushrooms, Spinach finished over Home made Tomato Sauce

$29.00 +

Vodka Sauce and Bacon Pie

Fresh mozzarella, vodka sauce and bacon

$30.95 +

Proto's Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, calamata olives, roasted peppers, mushrooms, beef smoked sausage

$32.95 +

Prosciutto Di Parma

Fresh mozzarella, Pecorino, garlic and arugula.

$32.95 +

Quattro Formaggi Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, Pecorino, Gorgonzola, Parmigiana and caramelized onions.

$30.95 +

Supreme Pizza

Pepperoni,Sausage,Onion,Mushrooms,Peppers and Olives

$36.00 +

Pizza of the Month


18” Chorizo and Jalapeno Pizza

Chorizo, jalapeno, red onions and a drizzle of Hot Honey

$31.95 +

Dessert Menu


Cannoli

$3.00

Nutella Calzone

Nutella, marscapone cheese and banana

$10.00

Proto's Pizza

A leading New York restaurant on Grubhub

50 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003
(212) 432-4044
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.Terms of usePrivacy policyCA privacy noticeDo not sell my info